Why Pray To Virgin Mary?

chittor-mother-mary-statue

Why should we pray to Virgin Mary? The reasons are many.

Why do Catholics pray to Mother Mary? Is Rosary really powerful?

The intercession of Mother Mary is very powerful as Jesus cannot neglect His mothers commands.This can be proved by the first miracle Jesus did at the wedding at Cana. – (John 2:1-11). Mother Mary told Jesus “They have no more wine.” And what was the final result? He turned water into wine.

In “The Poem of the Man-God” by Maria Valtorta, she says that Jesus told her about this incident as “I did it for Mary”. This proves that the intercession of Mother Mary is very very strong.

Mother Mary was blessed with Holy Spirit abundantly. We can see this as we read “At that time Mary got ready and hurried to a town in the hill country of Judea, where she entered Zechariah’s home and greeted Elizabeth. When Elizabeth heard Mary’s greeting, the baby leaped in her womb, and Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit.” (Luke 1:39-41) ; just by Virgin Mary’s greeting.

Listen to the talk from Apologetics on Mary, Purgatory and The Bible

What the angels thought on this matter:-

When angel appeared before Zechariah,father of John, angel just greets him by his name ,nothing more although he was “upright in the sight of God, observing all the Lord’s commandments and regulations blamelessly.” – (Luke 1:6)

When angel appeared before Joseph, the greeting was like this: “an angel of the Lord appeared to him in a dream and said, “Joseph son of David, do not be afraid to take Mary home as your wife, because what is conceived in her is from the Holy Spirit.” – (Matthew 1:20). Angel greeted him ‘son of david’, thats all.

Now let us see how did the angel greet Virgin Mary. It goes like this: “The angel went to her and said, “Greetings, you who are highly favored! The Lord is with you.” (Luke 1:28). See the difference….

Also read the article Mary, The Mystical Rose

2,540 thoughts on “Why Pray To Virgin Mary?”

  1. Hi Liam

    The trouble is that what you call water is poison and what you call truth is just RC Dogma.

    Jesus is not my brother, Mary is not my mother.

    Thomas addressed Jesus as “My Lord and My God” not “my brother”. Nobody in the NT ever addressed Jesus as “my brother”.

    You may not doubt it but God condemns it, Jesus instructs against it and Paul calls it false.

    Jesus said we should pray to Our Father, not our mother. Paul teaches us to make our requests “known to God” not to Mary. God Almighty says that we must not make idols nor bow down to them nor pray to them.

    There is not one single NT scripture that indicates that we should do what the RC says we should. How can we be imitating God if we worship Mary? Mary worshipped God not the other way round.

    I pray that you will break free from this deception and stop venerating the donkey rather than the rider.

    Phil

  2. Hi Phil, It was not my intention to contribute any further for the truth has been expressed via a number of contributers,however,it is not the first time in my 70 years that satan has used others to bite at my heels therefore I oppose him through Yourself.

    Jesus, as implied in your last comment, taught a prayer to his followers and it begins-‘Our Father’.That Father is also the Father of Jesus.If persons have the same Father they are brothers and sisters.Thus Jesus is Our Brother being divine and human.Divinity from God the Father and humanity from the Blessed Virgin.In fact,Phil, you are my brother.

    By denying Jesus as your brother you are denying God as your Father.But then again your frequent attacks on Mary fits in with your satanic influenced comments.For only satan would hold such demonic opinion.Especially referring to the Mother of Jesus as a ‘donkey’.
    I now pray for you….

  3. You cannot oppose satan through me silly boy.

    That we are adopted sons makes us adopted sons, it doesn’t make us brothers to the unique Son of God. The catechism will confirm that I am right :-)

    I didn’t refer to Mary as a donkey, I used the donkey as an illustrative point. The donkey carried Jesus but the donkey was honoured by that act not because of something worthy about the donkey.

    Phil

  4. Well Said Phil.

    1 Corinthians 1:8
    The language of the cross remains nonsense for those who are lost.

    Only God can open their eyes. In their mind ONLY Mother and Rosary. no father and son.
    Rgds

  5. Phil and Babu, Are you members of the same so called ‘Christian denomination’ or are you in separate denominations.If the latter then why?Jesus established one Church and even Protestant scholars agree that that Church was the Catholic Church!Of course there were those who contended that the Church had gone astray and needed to be reformed.In fact there were those within the Church at the time who agreed that some reforming was required but unfortunately rather than reform within the inevetable happened based upon human ego and in due course the Lutheran,Calvin,Anglican,etc.,were formed not associated with the Church of Christ.But inspite of the divisions each still claiming to be the original.
  6. The Bible confirms that Jesus established ONE Church.Babu and Phil are not members of it therefore they are admitting that they are heretics.
    I wonder do they share membership in the same so called Christian denomination and if not – why not?

  7. Along with Mary’s ‘yes’ to being the mother of Jesus at the Annunciation (LK 1:26f),the principal scriptural basis for the doctrine of Mary as Spiritual Mother of all of humanity is found in John 19:26-27.John “the beloved disciple”was told by Jesus that Mary was his mother when Jesus told John “Behold your mother”.He also said to his mother”…behold your son”Thus John is a symbol of all humankind-and that is why Mary is our spiritual mother.But inspite of God’s word there are those who adhere to the written word of scripture and yet deny the truth therein.

    Now,in the rich doctrine of the Mystical Body according to Paul(cf.Col 1:18,Eph 4:15), Christ is the Head of the Body,and the Catholic Church is the Body of Christ.Mary,then,in conceiving Jesus,the Head of the Mystical Body,also conceived all the faithful since as followers we are all members of the same Body.In giving birth to the Head Mary also gave birth to the Body,the Church.So,Mary,in giving physical birth to Jesus made it possible for His members to receive spiritual life through Jesus.It is for this reason that Mary is our true “Spiritual Mother”.

  8. Liam

    Jesus established one church and many churches (just as your RC theologians will tell you). There is one church (the church invisible) which contains all Christians and there are various visible assemblies of Christians.
    That there was never Roman or Petrine oversight of the churches visible from the NT because at no point is Peter ever used as a point of authority or said to be head over any church let alone all the churches.

    Indeed when the churches squabbled none of them claimed to be a petrine Christian.

    Of course your organisation claims that I am a heretic but then it is itself heretical so I guess it has to.

    If the Church of Christ is the RCC then could you explain why it is a whore that sits on 7 hills and not a bride?

    Phil

  9. The Catholic Church is indeed the body of Christ and the bride of Christ.

    The RCC on the other hand is a whore that sits on 7 hills and drinks the blood of the saints.

    The Popes are antiChrist, wicked men who teach that they are god on earth. I spit on them and their wicked lies.

  10. phil
    This is it. now i get the whole point of you people opposing the Catholic Church. till this point you people misinterpret Bible History and now you misinterpret the Future as well. if you don’t stop this direct attack on the Catholic Church you will surly face the Wrath of The Almighty. It was THE HOLY SPIRIT who instigated the Church, ill-treating the Church is ill-treating the SPIRIT HIMSELF and you are going to pay of this.

  11. I don’t oppose the Catholic Church, I oppose the Romish church. Even the Pope doesn’t think that the Universal Church only contains Roman Catholics. Well this one doesn’t, in the past other Popes have said and taught differently.

    Ill treating Christians is an attack on Christ (not the Holy Spirit) have you not read Paul’s conversation with Jesus?

    Almighty God won’t be angry with me for attacking wickedness where it exists.

    Threaten away you silly chap I have no fear of the hollow and childish threats of those enslaved in the cult of Rome.

  12. Dear George,
    What you are taking about “Wrath of The Almighty”. LOL…
    dear friend read Book of revelation.then you will come to know who is going to face Wrath of The Almighty
    God bless you

  13. Phil,You have just put your foot in it!
    You are far removed from the sincere and decent members of the Protestant denominations who contribute and read this part of a wonderful Christian site.In fact you are a disgrace to the denominations but I still love you and am praying for you.

    Recall Jesus stated to Peter “…my church…”-not churches. Being allegedly Bible based you appear to lack an understanding of the inspired written word.

    Also you are lacking in knowledge for there are few of my contributions that you have answered or as in the recent matters your contributions are very unchristian.For Our Saviour stated “By this shall all men know that you are my followers that you have love one for another”.What you expressed recently was from the mouth of satan for there was no love.All contrary to God for God is love!!!

  14. Peter never worshipped Mother Mary
    Peter never used Rosary
    Peter never used Scapular
    Peter never made idols
    Peter never confessed to the priests
    Peter was a married man
    Peter never baptized infants
    Peter never worshipped the bread

    Dear Catholics open the Bible and find out the truth
    Jesus going to judge us based on his words . not on the basis of RCC theory.
    God bless you all

  15. Phil,
    As God’s representative on earth it is the Pope’s desire to bring all of you into communion with the Church of Jesus,that is,the ONE HOLY CATHOLIC ROMAN CHURCH.That is God’s will for Jesus prayed that you and I maybe ONE.He did not pray for splintering his body.Those of your ancestors who left Christ’s Church aeons ago were poor victims of satanic intrigue.The church led by the Pope extends back thousands of years to when it was established by Jesus.Due to the historic plantation of the church in Rome in due course the latter fact is a weak means of argueing your point.
    Popes have not said differently about important matters because this would be contrary to the guarantee given by Jesus that the Holy Spirit would guide it at all times and inspite of the ongoing attacke by satan-‘the gates of hell shall not prevail against it’.

  16. Liam – The Pope isn’t God’s representative on earth.

    The organisation now ruled by the Pope dates to the mid 1800’s when it’s last dogma was added. But there was never a universal church ruled from Rome until a Roman Emperor took control of the Roman organisation and killed veryone who opposed him. The organisation you belong to was founded in the blood of Christians.

    Oh and Peter was NEVER told he was the church. There isn’t any scripture that says it because it isn’t true.

    Neither was Peter the rock to which Christ refered – I can quote you the Fathers to prove that you have a false doctrine if you wish? So neither the scriptures, nor the tradition of the church make Peter or any supposed successor the head of the church. Jesus is the head of the church and the church is his body.

    The church doesn’t have 2 heads, just one and that is a heavenly one. It doesn’t have an earthly head because we don’t need a king or ruler other than God. You, like the Israelites, have chosen to subject yourselves to an earhtly ruler when God says not to.

    Phil

  17. Babu,
    How do you know ? Where you in the company of the 1st Pope at that time.Even Jesus was baptised by John – the Baptist.When I was conceived I bore the stain of the sin of our 1st parents and I was baptised to remove any trace of sin.
    Were you not?Are you still carry the sin of Adam and Eve?

  18. Phil,(820)
    Those with knowledge such as historians must be having a fantastic laugh at your expense.The so called organisation of which I am a member began in the mid 1800,s according to You.If so, then how does Luther break from the Catholic Church around approximately 200 years before and formed the Luthern Church?Or are you implying that Luther,a Catholic Priest,broke from another so called church?What was its name?
    What about Matt.16:18-19-“I for my part declare to you,you are ‘Rock’, and on this rock I will build my church,and the jaws of death shall not prevail against it,I will entrust to you the keys of the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you declare bound on earth shall be bound in heaven;whatever you declare loosed on earth shall be loosed in heaven”.
    Yes,Phil,the truth is the truth and I express it for unlike yourself I am not in the clutches of the father of lies- satan.
    Please contact a Catholic Priest for you are on a very dangerious path.

  19. Listen my brothers ans sisters, With all due respect Jesus made it clear that he is the only way to the father, no Mary Joseph but in the name of Jesus, our prayers are only delivered to God through Jesus, we should not pray to Mary but to God through Jesus Christ ,he is the only way to the father.

  20. Fellow Christians
    +
    Any Christian who takes the Scriptures seriously will meet the Mother of Jesus there.
    She who was near the cross of her Son on Calvary,she who was at the marriage feast of Cana with its symbolism of ONE CHURCH AND IT UNITED.The virgin who was committed to God then and in our messianic times of today.And recall her words at the Annunciation,so like a phrase of the Our Father,”Behold the handmaid of the Lord;be it done unto me according to ‘your’Word.” Anyone considering these facts from The Bible,if objective,can appreciate that the Mother of Jesus has ‘one will’with her Son and shares his prayer at the Last Supper,”Father,I will them to be with me whom you have given me,” his prayer for Christian unity.
    I know that as a Catholic I can at times be very polemic at my advocacy and love of her but that is my faith.She is not to be adored but venerated.Now Jesus came to us through Mary but we go to God-Our Father through Jesus by the grace of their Spirit.But underlying that is the reality of Mary’s ‘YES’which was freely given to Our Creator via Gabriel.
    In relation to Christian disagreements re Mary and her role in the Church of her Son I believe that alongside satanic intrigue and mis-understandings arising from various persons of the reformation period a common patrimony has been lost.And, in time, I believe that the Mother of God will become a factor of unity for unity is the wish of the one and only God.

  21. well said Stevans #821
    Matt.16:18-19-”I for my part declare to you,you are ‘Rock’, and on this rock I will build my church,
    Based on the above verse we think Peter is the rock. Now let’s see the scripture carefully who is the rock.
    Genesis 49:24 but his bow remained steady, and his arms nimble, because of the hand of the Mighty One of Jacob; because of the Shepherd, the Rock of Israel;

    In the above who is Jacob’s rock ? Peter or God/Jesus?

    2 Samuel 22:3 and my God, the rock in whom I take refuge.
    Psalm 31:3 Give heed to my plea, and make haste to rescue me. Be a rock of refuge for me, a strong fortress for my safety.

    In the above verses who is David’s rock? NOT Peter?

    Deu 32:4 He is the Rock, and perfect are all his works, just are all his ways.

    In the above verse who is Moses’s rock? NOT Peter

    Isaiah 8:14
    He will be a sanctuary and at the same time a stumbling-stone, the rock that brings down, for both houses of Israel.

    In the above verse who is Isaiah’s rock ? NOT Peter

    See what Paul said
    1 Corinthians 3:11 – No one can lay a foundation other than the one which is already laid, which is Jesus Christ.

    So who is the rock and foundation? NOT Peter

    See what Peter said
    1 Peter 2:6 Scripture says: See, I lay in Zion a chosen and precious cornerstone; whoever believes in him will not be disappointed.

    Peter himself saying he is the NOT the rock.
    Finally
    John 2:19 And Jesus said, “Destroy this temple and in three days I will raise it up.”
    Jesus refers “this temple” here. Who is the temple here? Jesus or the building?
    Same way Jesus mentioned “this rock ” in Mathew. From the above i am 100 % sure the rock is NOT Peter.
    Regards

  22. @Liam #820
    you are pointing this verse to prove that Peter is the rock and he got the keys.Matt.16:18-19-”I for my part declare to you,you are ‘Rock’, and on this rock I will build my church, and the jaws of death shall not prevail against it, I will entrust to you the keys of the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you declare bound on earth shall be bound in heaven; whatever you declare loosed on earth shall be loosed in heaven”.

    Now after 2 chapter ( Mathew 18:18)Jesus giving the same authority to everyone. Also read John 20:23
    Now let’s see who got the keys in Scripture

    Isaiah 22:22
    Upon his shoulder I will place the key of the House of David: what he opens, no one shall shut; what he shuts, no one shall open.

    Revelation 1:18
    and mine are the keys of death and the netherworld.

    Revelation 3:7
    “Thus says he who is holy and true, who holds the key of David; if he opens, nobody shuts and if he shuts nobody opens.

    Peter clearly saying he is the not the head of the church

    1 Peter 5:1 I now address myself to those elders among you; I, too, am an elder and a witness to the sufferings of Christ, hoping to share the Glory which is to be revealed.

    dear Liam open the bible and follow the living Jesus… not dead people
    God bless you
    Rgds

  23. Dear Brothers and Sisters in Jesus Christ
    What a kind of people you are. Who ever opposing the catholic church please listen, this is not the worldly matters always fighting like this,See dear brothers You and I believe in Jesus after 2000 years, He came to this world he lived a miraculous life he did more miracles he died for our sins, on third day he raised from death and on 40th day he Ascended to Heaven and he got all the Power from the ALL-MIGHTY Father and from there he ruling the kingdom after all this we are believing in him we are telling he is our GOD, but think in other wise when Mother Mary accepted him in those days where the Judaism were there that time if a woman conceived before marriage means they will stoning on her and they will kill her in that time itself she believed in the word of GOD and surrendered herself to the will of GOD. It is not that much of easy that what we are sitting today in front of computer and arguing about her just imagine when she was somewhere she is 12 -14 year young girl when she surrendered herself to God’s will to save these world from the sin. for her we are giving some respect through showing love on her from our heart you people are opposing for this please think in general all ways don’t look in scripture itself in the BIBLE itself it is written that what ever it is there in the BIBLE is only that much which is required to know the love of GOD AND TO SAVE OURSELVES apart from this Jesus did many things.I am not telling that to reject the BIBLE it is everything for us apart from this we also have some love for the saints and others who lived for the church.

  24. @ jibson
    then who do you think the Rock is. don’t compare verses that doesn’t have any direct relation Jesus told about destroying the temple was His body of the Holy Spirit, it was His body that they destroyed it, and on the third day He built it up again. it was to foretell His Death and Resurrection, that has nothing to do with Jesus’ deceleration to St. Peter. no pope has ever boated themselves of there authority, it is the humbleness and meekness that the Holy Spirit gives His true servants. what right do you have to talk about those holy and chosen Shepherd you sinful fool.

  25. Babu,827,
    As quoted our God-man and Saviour very clearly stated that Peter was to be the basis of his Church and its 1st leader or father.Peter was also known as ‘Cephas’which in English is ‘rock’. In due course the successors of St.Peter called themselves ‘Popes’- which in English means ‘Father’.That is the Word of God’s statement to Peter which you have tried to make irrelevant.And in doing so you concoct an untruth by using the Holy Word of God.
    By his statement when he laid the basis for the Catholic Church Our Lord requested that as believers that we submit to the same divine authority,that of Christ the Head,who rules the Body through the visible head,our Holy Father the Pope,and the Bishops who are in communion with him.

    You refer in your contribution to ‘dead people’but those who die in Christ rise in Christ.That is biblically and traditionally based.

    In Matt 18-18 (which you quote) the Church has already come into being and Jesus is emphasising the importance of the Church which he based upon Peter ie ‘…tell it to the church;'(18-17).And remember ‘church’ not ‘churches’.

  26. Was Peter the rock upon which the church was built?

    What do the Fathers say? They don’t teach that Peter was superior to the other apostles or that Peter was the only rock upon which the church was built or indeed thay the position of Peter was passed to anyone.

    Here are a few quotes from the Fathers to show that what the RCC teaches is utterly contrary to what they taught.

    Tertullian

    If, because the Lord has said to Peter, ‘Upon this rock I will build My Church,’ ‘to thee have I given the keys of the heavenly kingdom;’ or, ‘Whatsoever thou shalt have bound or loosed in earth, shall be bound or loosed in the heavens,’ you therefore presume that the power of binding and loosing has derived to you, that is, to every Church akin to Peter, what sort of man are you, subverting and wholly changing the manifest intention of the Lord, conferring (as that intention did) this (gift) personally upon Peter? ‘On thee,’ He says, ‘will I build My church;’ and, ‘I will give thee the keys’…and, ‘Whatsoever thou shalt have loosed or bound’…In (Peter) himself the Church was reared; that is, through (Peter) himself; (Peter) himself essayed the key; you see what key: ‘Men of Israel, let what I say sink into your ears: Jesus the Nazarene, a man destined by God for you,’ and so forth. (Peter) himself, therefore, was the first to unbar, in Christ’s baptism, the entrance to the heavenly kingdom, in which kingdom are ‘loosed’ the sins that were beforetime ‘bound;’ and those which have not been ‘loosed’ are ‘bound,’ in accordance with true salvation…

    Origen

    And if we too have said like Peter, ‘Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God,’ not as if flesh and blood had revealed it unto us, but by the light from the Father in heaven having shone in our heart, we become a Peter, and to us there might be said by the Word, ‘Thou art Peter,’ etc. For a rock is every disciple of Christ of whom those drank who drank of the spiritual rock which followed them, and upon every such rock is built every word of the Church, and the polity in accordance with it; for in each of the perfect, who have the combination of words and deeds and thoughts which fill up the blessedness, is the church built by God.
    But if you suppose that upon the one Peter only the whole church is built by God, what would you say about John the son of thunder or each one of the Apostles? Shall we otherwise dare to say, that against Peter in particular the gates of Hades shall not prevail, but that they shall prevail against the other Apostles and the perfect? Does not the saying previously made, ‘The gates of Hades shall not prevail against it,’ hold in regard to all and in the case of each of them? And also the saying, ‘Upon this rock I will build My Church?’ Are the keys of the kingdom of heaven given by the Lord to Peter only, and will no other of the blessed receive them? But if this promise, ‘I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven,’ be common to others, how shall not all things previously spoken of, and the things which are subjoined as having been addressed to Peter, be common to them?
    ‘Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God.’ If any one says this to Him…he will obtain the things that were spoken according to the letter of the Gospel to that Peter, but, as the spirit of the Gospel teaches to every one who becomes such as that Peter was. For all bear the surname ‘rock’ who are the imitators of Christ, that is, of the spiritual rock which followed those who are being saved, that they may drink from it the spiritual draught. But these bear the surname of rock just as Christ does. But also as members of Christ deriving their surname from Him they are called Christians, and from the rock, Peters…And to all such the saying of the Savior might be spoken, ‘Thou art Peter’ etc., down to the words, ‘prevail against it.’ But what is the it? Is it the rock upon which Christ builds the Church, or is it the Church? For the phrase is ambiguous. Or is it as if the rock and the Church were one and the same? This I think to be true; for neither against the rock on which Christ builds His Church, nor against the Church will the gates of Hades prevail. Now, if the gates of Hades prevail against any one, such an one cannot be a rock upon which the Christ builds the Church, nor the Church built by Jesus upon the rock.

    Now those 2 Fathers are often misquoted, or partially quoted, as if they taught what the Romish church teaches but clearly once one reads what they wrote one sees that they are entirely opposed to the Romish View.

    What then do Roman Catholic Historians say? Do they agree with me or Rome?

    Robert B Eno

    “It is clear that in Cyprian’s mind…one theological conclusion he does not draw is that the bishop of Rome has authority which is superior to that of the African bishops.”

    Another RC Historian

    Cyprian used the Petrine text of Matthew to defend episcopal authority, but many later theologians, influenced by the papal connexions of the text, have interpreted Cyprian in a propapal sense which was alien to his thought…Cyprian would have used Matthew 16 to defend the authority of any bishop, but since he happened to employ it for the sake of the Bishop of Rome, it created the impression that he understood it as referring to papal authority…Catholics as well as Protestants are now generally agreed that Cyprian did not attribute a superior authority to Peter (Michael Winter, St. Peter and the Popes (Baltimore: Helikon, 1960), pp. 47-48).

  27. There is only one mediator that is our Lord JESUS Christ.Praying to Mary is absolutely foolishness.Mary was just a member of Jerusalem Church and witness of the coming of the Holy Spirit. She also worshiped Jesus. In the Church history clearly revealed that pray to Mary started after 300 AD by foolish priests

  28. I hope William, Liam got answer from #828
    @george- I think you didn’t read my reply. you still confused who is the Rock in scripture?
    So you think Jacob’s, Isaiah’s, Moses’s ,Hanna’s,David’s,Paul’s rock is Peter???? LOL
    Open your bible man…..read, don’t waste your time to kneel in front of sinful priests. Take time to find out the only mediator in bible.
    Even if 2 billion believe in one lie that will never become a truth, same way if no one believe in a truth that still a truth only. as Wilson said #829
    One God and One mediator. There is no multiple mediators.in this forum starting from #699 I am asking Catholics to show me ONE ( only one )verse saying mother mary is our mediator.
    Can anyone show me that verse?
    If you don’t have answer in Bible then it’s man-made/Vatican made! Don’t follow Rome follow Jesus.
    Rgds

  29. Phil (and Wilson),
    Listen to what Holy Scripture states not commentators on the Scriptures.It is there in black and white.Don’t manipulate the contents of the Bible to back up your prejudice positions.

    Be logical! Jesus referred to ‘one Church’ and people of your mind-set have established thousands of denominations and some of their founders claim that their denomination is the church Jesus established at the beginning.But if so why are there so many? Why are there so much division and disagreement amongst the protestant denominations?Even to the extent of Bible interpretation!

    Are you a member of ‘a church’,Phil? Please let us know and if so is it Prebysterian,Lutheran or, what ever?

    To conclude,why should there be so much division amongst those of the so called ‘reformed’ denominations.Could it be a result of satanic intrigue in its war against Christ and therefore his Church which today is led by Pope Benedict.Christ’s representative who sincerely desires the return of all believers in Christ from outside the Church which he established so there can be one fold and one Shepherd.

  30. Liam lol

    Logic is the last refuge of the confused.

    Yes Christ established “one church, so which church was it? Acts 15 And he went through Syria and Cilicia, confirming the churches.” Was it one of those? all of them?
    Acts 18 “And when he had landed at Caesarea, and gone up, and saluted the church, he went down to Antioch.” That one? etc etc

    Clearly when the bible talks about a church it means a) A local gathering of Christians (as in “Likewise greet the church that is in their house.”) or b) The whole invisible church which consists of all Christians.

    So do I belong to a church? Yes? The Church? Yes. Do I think that the RCC or the Othodox or anyone else can claim to be “The Only Church”? Of course not since the bible tells us that is just stupidity.

    As for 1,000s of denominations lol There aren’t thousands of denominations. The reason is simple because most protestants don’t belong to “a denomination” they just belong to the local church.

    As for divisions and disagreements

    1) Those have existed since bible times
    2) The RCC also has them
    3) There will always be wolves in sheeps clothing

    So what was your point?

    Do tell me though how is it possible to be a proper RC one day, perfectly right with God etc and then a heretic the next day even though one hasn’t changed one’s opinions or views on anything?

    Shall I tell you?

    On Dec 7th 1854 a Roman Catholic could believe that Mary was a born sinner like all other human beings and he was orthodox and ok, but on Dec 8th he became a heretic and therefore cast out from the church and unable to recieve communion or have his prayers heard.

    Until 1826 the Inquisition was still murdering so called heretics.

    1)read your bible
    2)read your history

    Now tell me where most heresies arose

    1) Inside the leadership (priesthood)?

    or

    2) Among the laity?

    Now tell me why you slavishly follow priests?

    Phil

  31. The first historic indications of the existing veneration of Mary carried on from the apostolic era of the Church established upon Peter is present in the Roman catacombs.As early as the end of the 1st century to the 1st half of the 2nd century Mary is depicted in many frescoes with and without her divine son.
    A very significant one in the catacombs of St.Agnes is Mary depicted between St.Peter and St.Paul with her arms outstretched to both.This illustrates the recognisation by the Church in its apostolic phase of the maternal centrality of Jesus mother in the early years of his church.

  32. The most complete ancient PRAYER to Mary is preserved in the ‘Sub Tuum Praisidium’,which means ‘Under Your Protection’.It is dated 250 AD.Please note the depth of understanding by the 3rd century Church of Mary as having the power to intercede for spiritual protection:

    WE FLY TO YOUR PROTECTION,
    O HOLY MOTHER OF GOD,
    DESPISE NOT OUR PETITIONS
    IN OUR NECESSITIES,
    BUT DELIVER US FROM ALL DANGERS.
    O EVER GLORIOUS AND BLESSED VIRGIN

  33. Phil,
    We are all sinners that is why Jesus came to save us but because of satanic sin any one can do what happened evilly throughout the history of the human race and indeed the history of Christianity.That is why Jesus established the Catholic Priesthood-‘whose sins you shall forgive thay are forgiven,whose sins you shall retain they are retained’.
    The Catholic Church is an assembly of persons which can be seen and counted.It is a world-wide organisation and a divine reality.A people united by the Holy Spirit dwelling in our hearts.A church which the Word of God made man established and guaranteed its continuing existence via the sending of the Spirit in his absence.But the fact to be recognised is that this side of the grave we are prone to sin and there have been many sinful Catholics (yours truly) from Popes,etc,.
    For 3 years Jesus travelled and spoke of the Good News of The Kingdom while gathering around him a small group both male and female whom he instructed.They were the nucleus of the new people of God.And from them the chose 12 to be the leaders of his Church which he founded upon their leader Peter.Yes, Peter and the other 11 were given positions of authority and there is no doubt via the Bible and Tradition Peter was the leader.

  34. Liam

    So 250 years or so after Jesus some folks were already worshipping Mary. That would make it right how exactly?

    Less than that after the founding of the church all manner of heresies were abroad and Paul and others had to fight them.

    That you would discard the bible in favour of a hymn w